It’s hard to believe that legends of the silver screen could have been played by anyone else. Sometimes, however, it seems that casting drama in movies makes history in more ways than one. In other words, who doesn’t have their favourite character who could have been portrayed differently by a different actor.
From Spider-Man to The Joker, these options that were never taken would have had a completely different flow in the film or show.
So without further ado, let us explore the top 10 iconic roles that another actor was considered for and see just how close we were to some other kinds of movies. You will be shocked to learn who was once cast in your favourite role!
1. Michael Corleone, “The Godfather”
Al Pacino was an underrated theatre actor with a single movie to his name. Well, that was until he starred as Michael Corleone in Francis Ford Coppola’s ‘The Godfather’. Nothing defines one’s career quite like this role for Al Pacino. Hollywood history books could have been quite different owing to the political correctness of 2004 though. Instead, one of Hollywood’s heavyweights went and starred in his films that would become eyesores for ‘Washington’ including ‘One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest’ and ‘Chinatown’.
2. Rose, “Titanic”
James Cameron’s emotional and Oscar-awarded film scorched the earth for its main actors, Leonardo DiCaprio and Kate Winslet but only just. The part of a British aristocrat Rose was so close to becoming part of Goop Queen Gwyneth Paltrow.
The British actress commented on rumors spread by a radio discotheque Howard Stern claiming that she was offered but refused this role: “I think I was really in contention for it. I was down to one of the last two so yes there is some of my style in the part, though I regret certain things throughout the decades. This is a lesson for us all. What is the point of clinging onto roles?”
3. James Bond, “Casino Royale”
In a conducted interview with The Guardian, Bond producer Barbara Broccoli confirms that her team ‘haven’t even begun’ searching for a new 007. So it is going to be some time before we find out who is appropriate to replace Daniel Craig, although it is unlikely to be Henry Cavill… or is it?
In a previous podcast, Cavil mentioned that the last time the Broccolis considered him for the role, he and Craig were the other choice but he was the younger option and ‘was probably not ready for this role at the moment.’ So does this mean that now that he’s older, it would be ‘his’ role? Or the antonym? Only time will tell.
4. Vivian Ward, “Pretty Woman”
Among the films responsible for jumpstarting Julia Roberts’ career is “Pretty Woman.” To this day, more than three decades into the future, this film is classified as one—if complicated. However, this actress was almost succeeded by a different red-headed actor, Molly Ringwald, who declined the part because she disliked the narrative, saying in an interview with the Guardian ‘Even then, I felt like there was something icky about it.’
5. Black Widow, “The Avengers”
Scarlett Johansson has featured as Black Widow in four of The Avengers and her own stand-alone movie, the Black Widow. She was not the first choice for this role, however, but a second choice. Their first choice was Emily Blunt, but she could not take the role because she was busy with the production of 2010’s ‘Gulliver’s Travels’, a decision she says she regrets.
6. Neo, “The Matrix”
Before Keanu Reeves took on what would be his most iconic role, it was Will Smith who was offered, the role of Neo. At that time, Smith had recently appeared in “Men in Black” and “Independence Day” and didn’t want to be associated only as ‘the alien movie guy’. Later, that worry combined with a chaotic pitch meeting with the Wachowskis made Smith turn down “The Matrix”, a decision he would later regret the most throughout his career.
7. Patrick Bateman, “American Psycho”
Throughout the making of “American Psycho,” there were a lot of struggles with the feelings of Patrick Bateman’s relevancy within the movie, which led to the dismissal, and re-employment, of Mary Harron as the writer and director. When American Psycho went into production, it cast Christian Bale, a relatively unknown actor at the time, as its lead while the production’s initial decision was to cast Leonardo DiCaprio in the role. As a result, the studio replaced Harron and in turn, O. Stone was appointed as director who “in turn had DiCaprio’s aspiration” but the actor pulled it out. As it turned out, Harron was able to have Bale, her first choice, star in the film, which changed his career significantly.
8. Elle Woods, “Legally Blonde”
Reese Witherspoon’s Elle Woods in the movie “Legally Blonde” is arguably the most well-known character attributed to the actress. However, before Witherspoon made her casting decision, Christina Applegate rejected the role of the mouse on account of having already portrayed a similar character in the sitcom “Married with Children” and wishing to avoid repetitive typecasting.
9. Andy Sachs, “The Devil Wears Prada”
Before “The Devil Wears Prada” came to be, Anne Hathaway was mostly dependent on her teen dramas for survival. But the studio looked at Rachel McAdams for the role before Hathaway got the role of Andy. McAdams refused several times claiming she wished to pursue low profile projects.
10. Dumbledore, “Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban”
Richard Harris played Albus Dumbledore in the first two installments of ‘Harry Potter’, however, he passed away before the commencement of the third installment. Ian McKellen, who had acted in the ‘Lord of the Rings’ series as Gandalf the wizard, was approached to replace him but McKellen said no to the offer as, in his opinion, the late Richard Harris wouldn’t have liked him as an actor. The latter was instead played by Michael Gambon in the other series.